Keeping Up with the Calligraphers
The first of its kind - Alex Hirsch of Signed by Alex and Cat Brown of Cat Lauren Calligraphy, two event calligraphers with a combined decade of knowledge and experience in the industry are coming together to share what they know for artists + industry professionals alike!
Their values are rooted in collaboration and community above all else. Listen in to hear their honest conversations about the artist and event industries, and provide their insights on how we can collectively do better and be better in our creative communities.
Expect lots of unfiltered sassy banter, sarcasm on steroids, and lots of laughter between these two fire signs.
Keeping Up with the Calligraphers
"It's Not You, It's Your Messaging" w/ Alane Gianetti of Write Pretty For Me
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Alane Gianetti of Write Pretty For Me, wedding calligrapher and business coach, tells us all about her expertise on messaging: what it is, the importance of messaging in building a successful business, and actionable tips on improving and clarifying your brand message.
Alex and Cat get into examples of what's worked for them, and where they went wrong over the years. Find out if your messaging is attracting the right clients, and how to tailor your messaging to work for you, and communicate your value.
From $500 to $5k Free Training (Oct. 27 @3pm EST)
Follow us in all the places!
Podcast, Keeping Up with the Calligraphers
IG: https://www.instagram.com/keepingupwiththecalligs/
Alex Hirsch, Signed by Alex
IG: https://www.instagram.com/signedbyalex
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/signedbyalex
Website: https://www.signedbyalex.co
Cat Brown, Cat Lauren Calligraphy
IG: https://www.instagram.com/catlaurencalligraphy/
Website: http://www.catlaurencalligraphy.com/
Alex (00:09)
Hi everyone and welcome back to Keeping Up With The Calligraphers. This is Alex and...
Cat (00:14)
of Cat Lauren calligraphy and we have another guest episode today and I'll let her introduce herself. ahead.
Alane (00:19)
Hello, I'm Alayne of Write Pretty For Me.
Alex (00:22)
Amazing. Thank
Cat (00:22)
it works.
Alex (00:23)
you so much. We're so excited to have you. We have all done a recording before on your previous podcast, Calligraphy Biz Corner, where we talked about marketing your business and we had a great discussion on there. So we already know that we're in good hands. And yeah, so I just wanted to mention we previously have collaborated with each other. So this isn't necessarily a new voice, but we do have her solo today talking about
a particular subject which is messaging. messaging is really important in your business and we feel like it is something that a lot of people need to hear right now.
Cat (01:00)
percent.
Alex (01:02)
As... Cat's eyes are so wide right now. Yes! So before we get started on the topic we'd love to dive in. You've been a full-time calligrapher, you're pivoting into coaching,
Give us a brief rundown of your lore. Like, how do you start, how do you get to where you are?
Alane (01:18)
Yeah, absolutely. So first off, thank you so much for having me. I'm so glad that we're back in each other's circles doing another collaboration together because last time was so fun. So yeah, I am a wedding calligrapher turned into a business coach for calligraphers, stationers, live event artists. But I started my business back in 2016. I went full time in 2018. And then it was around 2020 that I started to dabble in the coaching education space.
really more just like answering people's questions, right? Because I feel like as a calligrapher, you do naturally build an artist of other calligraphers. So as my Instagram was growing and other calligraphers, stationers, know, just creative artists and service providers started to follow me, they would pop into my DMs just of like, can I pick your brain on this? Or how do you price this? know, what do you do when a client asks for a discount? Like all of these little things. So.
I'm pretty much an open book I have I love connecting with people I have no problem popping into DMS and giving them answers or just helping point them in the right direction that felt totally natural to me. So it was in 2020 when weddings were on pause and we were all just kind of like, what the heck are we doing with our time?
Cat (02:26)
Now what? Yeah.
Alex (02:27)
Yeah.
Alane (02:28)
I had started to have a bit of a pricing conversation I think it had started started on my stories I forget what the actual like
topic was, but I started to just dive into pricing because I know that's always such a hot topic in the calligraphy industry, right? Because
I feel like especially
Alex (02:43)
Yeah.
Alane (02:44)
when you just when you're just starting, we're like, what do you price? How much do you charge for an envelope? How much do you charge for a sign? How much do you charge to be on site? And my DMS were just like flooded with responses to that. So as we were just kind of sitting there, twiddling our thumbs during COVID, I was like, why don't I just hop on a zoom and if you want to come and
I'll just kind of go over my rundown of how I price in my work and if you take something away from it, great. So go ahead.
Alex (03:11)
Was
pricing for like wedding signage, stationary, live events? Like what were you talking about at the time that kind of attracted people to that conversation?
Alane (03:22)
Yeah, it was mainly weddings and stationary. So like, but I would say even more so just like calligraphy on envelopes, spot calligraphy, things like that. And I didn't necessarily get into the nitty gritty of like, here's how much you should charge for a welcome sign or how much you should charge for your envelopes,
Cat (03:38)
Yeah.
Alane (03:39)
but really into like my pricing theory and strategy and how I come up with my pricing. Because at the end of the day, pricing is also just so personal. And I always want to
That's why I'm always a little hesitant to have pricing conversations because people's pricing is going to look very different. But I do still think that there's a framework and strategy that you can kind of teach around it. So that was really exciting
Alex (04:01)
So.
Alane (04:02)
to be able to do that. And then to see how many people had showed up. So that was my like original dabble into education. And then from there, it just kind of turned into some one off clarity calls, I developed a little more structure around it. And then eventually it turned into the
kind of full coaching ecosystem that I have today where I have a signature group program. I have some advanced containers built off of that.
Cat (04:24)
amazing.
Alex (04:24)
What do you feel like
this wasn't sorry we didn't write this down. What do you feel like was the
Alane (04:29)
We're still good.
Alex (04:29)
thing that attracted people to asking you questions? Because I will say I feel like there's there's a lot of calligraphers online. I mean I know in my own little city there's not that many and like people I'm the only calligrapher people know right? But in our little bubble there's a lot there's a lot a lot a lot. like what do you think like kind of made you stand out to have that sort of like
that interest because I feel like it
Alane (04:54)
That's a great question.
Alex (04:56)
kind of relates to what we're talking about. I feel like it kind of relates to messaging. Sorry if I took the answer.
Alane (05:03)
No, no, no, no, I
definitely think it does. I mean, I think, I think first off, it was people kind of watched my journey, people who had been with me for a while of like, I started calligraphy as a hobby, then I turned it into a business, then because I was sharing back in like, 2016, when I was really just sharing like, personal projects on Instagram, in the hopes that maybe someday somebody would hire
Alex (05:26)
Yeah.
Alane (05:26)
me, right. That
Cat (05:27)
Yeah.
Alane (05:28)
was my portfolio. But they watched that progression from
hobby to side hustle to actually taking it full time and then building a, you know, booked out calligraphy business as I was full time. So I think first off, it was just kind of like they were intrigued by the journey. But then I think part of it was to your point, the messaging of I definitely was also speaking to other calligraphers sometimes in my content, which we'll get into.
But, and I would share things like on my stories or in posts, more about the process or a little more about the business that I think opened doors for people to kind of come into my DMs. And then I'm gonna assume that part
of it is also just like my personality of being warm and open and welcoming. At least I like to think I am.
Alex (06:10)
You are, you are, you are.
Cat (06:12)
Yeah, when I think to we were talking 2020 2019 2020 like they're really there still isn't like there's more now in terms of like mentors and like calligraphers that are doing more in education but especially then like there really wasn't a lot at the time and I feel like so many people were like hungry for that information and you weren't putting it behind a paywall like you were just openly like
sharing the information, everyone was like starved for information. That's when a lot of people were picking up new hobbies and things like that during COVID. So I feel like there's a lot that was like going into it at the time, really good timing, honestly. people were just ready for the information. You capitalized on it.
Alane (06:53)
Yeah, exactly. Because yeah, it's like we were all and a lot of people were kind of pivoting, right? Like whether it was they were pivoting their calligraphy services or pivoting whatever they were doing, as far as their own business, or it's like, they were working full time, and then they got furloughed or whatever the case may be. Like I think that there was just a lot of change going on. And to your point, I think that people were very hungry for information and for learning and developing new hobbies or trying to start their own business because they
We're like, okay, well, I don't want to go back to the workforce or going into an office every day or whatever the case
Cat (07:26)
Yeah.
Alane (07:26)
may be.
Cat (07:27)
Yeah.
Alex (07:27)
here here.
Cat (07:28)
I feel like as your program has been developing, and as you've really been like, leaning into what your coaching style is going to be, and the content you're going to be coaching on, I've seen you talk a lot about messaging. And it's just a conversation, I feel like calligraphy world the niche is ready for and maybe they don't even know it. How did you land there?
Alane (07:47)
Yeah, so messaging is actually like the very first thing that we do inside of my group coaching program together. And it's because we'll get into this in a minute of just like how I see it as truly the foundation of everything else. But it really started with me and my own business because I got to the point where I was super proud of my work. Like I liked my style. I felt like it was very developed and refined. I was confident in my
craft, like I felt really good about the visual aspect of my business. And that did indeed carry me from, you know, when I started in 2016 to taking my business full time in 2018 to where I was at in 2021, where I was kind of just like, in full demand, overbooked, which some might think is a good thing. I ended that year being like that was the worst year ever. But all about to say
I was feeling like, well, my work's really good. So that's just gonna like continue to speak for itself and continue to carry me forward. But I hit a point in my business and it really was 2021 where I was I was super confident in everything and like, this is worth the price and this is worth what I'm charging and whatnot. But I was still getting pricing pushback. I was getting people you know, haggling me over $150 welcome sign. I was getting clients who only wanted to do like
just one bar sign instead of the full package, which is what I really wanted to be doing. And so I realized that my work being really good just wasn't enough. Like I had been operating under the assumption that if my portfolio was strong enough, then people would just say yes, they wouldn't bulk at my prices, etc. But that wasn't the case at all. And I realized that it came down to my messaging wasn't doing
the second layer of like the job of communicating who I was for, what kind of work I actually wanted to be doing, what kind of clients I wanted to be working with, why my pricing made sense for the experience that I was delivering. So it really wasn't until I got that clear that everything started to shift for me in the positive direction, like help take me to that next level.
of, finally the right clients finding me the wrong ones filtering themselves out before they even reached out via my contact form. I feel like I wasn't having to justify my prices as much anymore because my messaging was kind of doing that work for me even before people actually landed in my inbox. So it was my own experience that really brought me to making messaging like the cornerstone and kind of the foundational
that we do first together inside of my group coaching program because I see the same pattern with the calligraphers that I work with of, know, they have beautiful, amazing work. Like they're super talented, but messaging just isn't pulling the weight that it needs to pull, especially in today's world where, you know, calligraphy is still such a niche industry, but it is, I don't want to say it's saturated market, but you do still need something that's going to differentiate you from the next calligrapher because your clients need to know.
Well, why should I hire cat over Alex or Elaine over cat or like whatever it is, right. And that's not in a competition way by any means. It's just we're each going to be for a very different client. And that's totally okay. But that's also what we want. And we want our clients to understand that.
Alex (11:03)
Yeah, I want to reiterate for anyone who's listening that we've said this on previous podcasts too. so I love that you're like doubling down on it is that it's not necessarily your talent like or your lack of talent, right? That's not getting you gigs or whatever it might be or projects.
and that like your clients that make sense for you will find you through how you're presenting yourself, how you're marketing yourself, through your style, through your uniqueness. Like Cat and I joke sometimes like certain clients that she'll get, I'm like, that's so you and all certain clients all get and she'll be like, that's so you, right? And it just, makes so much sense. And I think that's based on having
messaging that makes sense for each of us individually. So I just want to double down on that for anyone who's listening because we do say this a lot and we've said it in previous episodes, but I just think it's so important, hence why we're chatting about it again today.
Cat (11:57)
Yeah, I agree. For anybody that's listening to this and maybe like the term feels really ambiguous, maybe we can jump into like what messaging is. I know when I was in that like ready to pivot mode, I was like, what the fuck is a brand? I don't know what the fuck messaging is. And it took me a really long time to figure out, but kind of similarly to you and my journey, once that clicked for me and I really felt good about all of that stuff, I was like, my God.
this is what I was missing. Everything feels so crystal clear about like the content I have to make, what my website should say, like all of these things that really became so clear. But until I like got over the hump of like, what the fuck even is this? Like I was lost. So can we like maybe define that term for the listeners?
Alane (12:37)
Yeah, absolutely. So I kind of define messaging as like all of the language that you're using to communicate your value. So what you do, who you serve, what somebody gets out of the experience of working with you, why your pricing makes sense. It's really what creates and establishes your positioning in the market. And then literally to your point, like it is the foundation for everything else that you do in your business from marketing to client experience to pricing. And
One of the things that I'm kind of noticing with calligraphers that I'm having conversations with about messaging is it's easy to think that it's just one thing like it's just my Instagram bio or it's just my captions or it's just my website copy but it's all of those things working together like I kind of like to think of you've got messaging on the front end like the outward facing part of your business so everything that people are seeing on the outside before they actually like walk into the door of your business so you know your Instagram
your website, a LinkedIn profile, like your content, blog posts, all of that kind of stuff. But then it also encompasses everything that's happening behind the door of your business when somebody actually gets in, like what are the emails? What are the proposals? How is that like language and messaging working to continue to reaffirm to the person who's inquired that yes, you are in the right place. I am the right calligrapher for you.
I'm gonna take care of you. Like I'm building trust. I'm building confidence, all of those things.
Alex (14:02)
I like that you said it's the back end of stuff too, because again, this is something Cat and I joke about, but it's like people who want something super urgent.
are gonna immediately know that like I'm not their person because that's not like who I am and that's not how I operate as a human being and also not how I operate in my business. Like I'm not gonna be like, yeah, I'll respond in like five minutes to your text, your email, your Instagram message or whatever. Especially don't call me in the middle of the day if we don't have something scheduled. whereas there are people who operate with that sort of frequency.
and that's for them, right? So I think it also is, how you move, it's your energy. And I think, you know, the messaging is, that's also part of your messaging, right? Like your cadence, right?
Alane (14:42)
Yeah, your vibe, right? Like,
Alex (14:45)
Yeah.
Alane (14:46)
yeah, yep, exactly. Exactly. And, you know, your messaging really has one job for your business. And it's just to make your ideal client feel like they are in the right place. They found the right person, they can trust you 100 % to deliver on whatever it is that they're hiring you for. And that just has to be consistent to from like the very first piece of content that they see or whatever kind of catches their eye out in the world.
all the way through proposal sitting in their inbox or following up with them at the end of the job for review or you know, however long that kind of relationship tends to last for you in your business. It's also really important that it's consistent from piece to piece, right? Like if you're to your point, Alex of like the whole vibe. If you're super bubbly on your Instagram and filled with energy, but then your website reads like a corporate brochure, like that's going to create such a disconnect in your client's mind and they're going to
Cat (15:38)
Yeah.
Alane (15:38)
probably like if they're in your Instagram clicking around like my gosh, I'm so excited. I want to reach out to this person. Let me pop over to their website. And now it's a totally different vibe. They're probably going to first be like, am I even in the right place? Like is this the same person?
Alex (15:53)
Yeah, no, I've definitely I've
Cat (15:52)
Yeah. Yeah.
Alex (15:54)
had people that I've walked into an event and they go, my gosh, you're exactly like your website. And I go, thank you.
Alane (16:00)
Okay.
Alex (16:02)
Are people not like, but I think sometimes
Alane (16:03)
Yeah!
Alex (16:04)
people might be using an outdated photo or outdated
Alane (16:07)
Mm-hmm.
Alex (16:07)
language or it's not really representing themselves how like online versus on their website versus how they present in person. So that's such a good point because I've literally had people
Cat (16:17)
Yeah, no, and that would,
Alex (16:18)
say that.
Cat (16:18)
especially with like live events coming up, imagine the disconnect between like maybe your copy is super bubbly and outgoing and fun and all these things, but maybe you're more like introverted and you get on site and there's that disconnect of like, wait, like, and there's not anything wrong with being more reserved or like shy or just like not as bubbly or anything like that. But if you have that disconnect, because maybe you saw.
someone else's copy or someone else's post went really viral and you're like, I want to do that too. And then like that's not you and you tried that on for yourself and now you just like feel naked and exposed on site. that's going to reflect on you. That's going to reflect on your client. that disconnect is going to be crazy across the board.
Alane (16:56)
Great, yeah, exactly. And that's why you need the messaging to bolster the visuals, your portfolio, your beautiful work, your talent. people, and especially with, I mean, yes, with wedding calligraphy, because when you are kind of that like full service provider, like I have been like, I establish a relationship with my clients. And that's one of the things that I love about it, right?
So they also need to make sure that they like me as a person when they're hiring me, but that's even more important, like you said, for the live event. So you wanna make sure that that is consistent and people aren't just seeing your work, they're also starting to get a feel for what kind of vibe or what kind of energy would she bring to our event or how would she fit inside of our brand culture or whatever it is that we're trying to promote with this activation, et cetera.
Cat (17:38)
Yeah, no, I agree. So I'm curious now that you've been like really consistently coaching quite a bit and you've been working with a lot of calligraphers like over the years, but like really, really intentionally over the last couple of months, years maybe, what is like the fastest way that you can tell someone really is like lacking that messaging clarity? Like where is, how is that showing up? I wanna give people some like tangible points.
Alane (18:02)
Yes. So before I dive into this, I just feel like I have to make an important distinction because I am going to talk about like clarity and specificity in your messaging. But I don't want that to be confused with the idea of niching down because that's not what I'm saying. You can definitely be a multifaceted artist, a multifaceted calligrapher. You you can offer a variety of different services to completely different clients, but
it's going to be how are you talking about each of those services? That is what needs to be super clear and super specific. So one of like the fastest ways that I can tell that people aren't there that they don't have clarity in their messaging is when it is super generic and blends in with every other calligrapher. you know, seeing and like an Instagram bio, you know, custom calligraphy or calligraphy for live events. And all of us have had messaging at some point like that, right? Like I started there as well. But
The biggest problem with that type of messaging is that it tells me what you do, which is great, but like every other calligrapher also probably does custom calligraphy or some sort of calligraphy for live events. But it doesn't tell me who you're for or why I should work with you over another calligrapher. It doesn't really make me feel anything while I'm reading it. It basically just tells me that you exist as a calligrapher, but that's it. And so I think that
you know, generic messaging is kind of the fastest way to stay hidden, right? Because you're not actually allowing yourself to be known for anything. And it's an easy trap to fall, like I fell into it too, until I kind of hit my turning point, but I think it feels safe to stay generic because you worry that if you narrow down on your messaging, you're gonna exclude people or rule them out or like,
I think the ultimate fear is that you're gonna leave money on the table by being more specific, right? So like, if I can serve everyone, then I'll be able to take on all of these different clients and book all these different jobs and make all of this money. But that's the fastest way to just stall your business, because that's literally what happened to me. And when you're for everyone, you're not gonna be for anyone.
Alex (20:09)
Yeah, I think that's exactly right. And I think it's so important for people to show up as themselves. And I...to bring it deeper, I think it's really hard to find your voice and to find...to figure out who you are in this current state. Like, just as a human being.
And so I think it also goes into doing a little bit of like deeper work within yourself because once you know who you are and you have a solid sense of self, it's so much easier to then show up in your business as yourself, to then show up for your clients as yourself. I mean, people know I stand 10 toes down on a lot of like left leaning political things. So.
it's very easy. People go, my god, you're so brave, and it's like, well no, I'm just like literally being who I am, and that came with practice for being who I am outside of my business, and then bringing it in there as well so that I get clients like the ACLU and Planned Parenthood, right? Like, and then I could better serve those people as well, and so I think that scares the shit out of people. Yes, you might isolate some people, people might not...
like that. And having a fear of conflict is also very difficult. I will say I don't, I thankfully don't have a lot of people coming into my DMs with any sort of like, I hate you and you're the worst, whatever. But
I do think like once you continue to show up as yourself in your personal life and develop your sense of self and who you are personally, it also I mean, sorry, I just I feel like I went full therapy there, but
Alane (21:48)
No, but it's so true. And like
that is the deep work. Like nobody, we can throw like you can listen to this episode and get all of the messaging tips and tricks or you know, tells of you know, this is how you can be more specific. This is where you're being too generic. But we're none of us are going to be able to hand a calligrapher listening to this their messaging on a silver platter. And I was talking about messaging inside of my broadcast channel on Instagram. And I had a question with like a couple poll answers of
I think it was something like why, what is what is your biggest struggle when it comes to your messaging? And the top answer was like, I don't know how to say what I do and who I'm for. And it's like, okay, but I that's great that you're aware of that. But like, I can't help you with that. Like, that's the deep work that you
Cat (22:32)
Right.
Alane (22:32)
have to do is figuring out what are your values? What kind of clients do you actually like to work with? Like you said,
What do you stand for? What don't you stand for? What's important to you? What's not? What's your why behind this? Like all of those things. And to your point, sometimes it's hard to like really get quiet and be that honest with yourself.
Alex (22:53)
Yeah,
I mean, I'm still afraid sometimes, like not to say sometimes I'll put something up and then if I
Alane (22:57)
Yes.
Alex (22:59)
get like, you know, in my head and I take it down at like in five minutes later, wait, no, that was too personal. don't want to share that.
Cat (23:06)
Yeah.
Alane (23:06)
Right?
Alex (23:07)
So it does happen.
Cat (23:09)
curious
Alane (23:09)
Yep.
Cat (23:09)
just out of curiosity for both of you and we might not have like a firm answer on it but I know for me it took me probably I had one event that was like a turning point of like I could fucking do things way different in my business and I'm about to and from there to
like my rebrand like
If anyone has been following me, was the one Ashley Benson event where I was like, I'm fucking showing up in a corset and I don't give a fuck. That's what I'm doing. And I literally was like, my God, I can run my business so differently. I'm ditching the pink immediately because I fucking hate pink. Why is that even my brand? All of these things. And I had a full on crisis. But from there to where I was like, hell yeah, I feel so good about my messaging, my copy, my website, my brand, all of those things.
very transparently, it took me probably, I would say 18 months to two years to really sit down and like go through all of that and make what was in my brain be able to get down on paper or onto my keyboard and then into the world. And it costs me a lot of fucking money because I paid for somebody to help me get a brand and all of those things. So.
Sorry, I'm on soapbox now, but I think a lot of when I'm like looking out in the calligrapher world, it feels like a lot of people want things to be solved in a DM. They wanna reach out to someone that they feel like has made it or they're where they wanna be. And they're like, hey, how about you do this? Like it's that link culture of like, can you send me the link to what templates you use for this or whatever? And I just wanna be so honest and so transparent about how...
much investment that took in terms of my time, my money, and just like my mental capacity to be able to show up consistently now. So I just wanna throw that out there. That is what I'm seeing, but I'm curious if that was similar for you guys, if that was different.
Alex (24:58)
I'll you go first.
Alane (24:59)
Okay. Yeah, no, I mean, yes, very similar. I mean, I feel like my big turning point was my 2021 year that I talk about a lot because it also is what spurred some of my coaching because I'm like, nobody else should get to where I was where like I made $100,000 and was miserable and wanted to burn it all
Cat (25:15)
Yeah.
Alane (25:15)
down. Like, that should have been the most exciting point in my business. And it was the word it was like the lowest point of my business. And I was like, what is happening? And to your point, it's like, okay, no.
No, no, no. If I'm going to keep going, I have to build this business in a way that it actually works for me for what lights me up for what is going to be sustainable going forward. And same thing that took a lot of work. It took investing in business coach and a rebrand eventually. And like all of those things that I had been putting off, because I do think that you can get to a point in your business. Like we were all scrappy and everybody who's listening to this is scrappy, right? It takes scrappiness to become a business owner.
And you can figure it out, but there does come a point to what got you to where you are right now isn't going to get you to where you're going next. it requires totally different equipment or a totally different vehicle or yeah,
Cat (26:07)
mindset. Yeah.
Alane (26:10)
exactly. Like you've got to do some deeper work because I also think what happens is when we start, at least for me, it was like,
your business kind of gets built reactively a little bit,
Cat (26:22)
Your clients end up kind of telling
you like who your brand or your business is going to be just based because you're being scrappy. You're trying to make money. You're trying to try on all the hats.
Alane (26:30)
Exactly. And you're
saying yes to things, which is all so great. And I feel like you learn so much in that stage. So I would
Cat (26:36)
Yeah.
Alane (26:36)
never say to skip it. But there does come a point where you can't build reactively anymore. And you
Cat (26:40)
You can't. No.
Alane (26:42)
have to start to root it in. What do I actually want? And what do I want this to look like?
Cat (26:47)
No. Alex will bet you.
Alex (26:48)
Yeah.
I can't say I had one big like pivot moment, because unfortunately I've been who I am forever since I was Fortunately
Cat (26:59)
I forbid a woman have consistency!
Alex (27:02)
and unfortunately. But I will say, to your points, it's not overnight and I think it takes a lot of practice.
and you can't skip that part. And I think we're all evolving constantly. So there's two things. One, think, you know, I really, same as you, like I have been burning myself fucking out for the past couple of years and it's like, for what? Like, what the fuck? And so now I'm struggling in, on the other side of things where I'm like, I asked for more balance.
because
So that's my next pivot of like, okay, I am now trying to practice what I preach in don't, don't bring yourself out and, you know, manage your project load a little bit better and space things out and blah, blah, blah, right? So that's my current pivot is, okay, how do I get into a space where I'm okay with this new chapter? And then the second thing is,
narrowing the gap of that, I think is what kind of what you're mentioning is you can be in that phase, and you could be practicing and you can be doing all those things, but what I'm hearing is that you can make that time of practice a lot shorter if you talk to someone about it like Alane and you really figure out where you're stuck.
and where you need to go and where you need to move forward because I think we can stay in that stuff for really long time and it's up to you if you want to shorten that narrow that gap or if you're okay with kind of sitting in it for a minute.
Cat (28:30)
Yeah, sorry, I took us like way down a rabbit hole.
Alane (28:33)
No, I
love it.
Cat (28:35)
so trying to get us back on track here. So we just like talk through the messaging
and all that jazz and like what kind of those telltale signs were. I feel like we kind of talked through why it's important, but I kind of want to talk about a little bit more too of
how it's been showing up lately and what that cost is of not doing that and where that gap is between I'm spinning my wheels, I feel like I'm doing all this work and this content, but I'm not getting that return. I wanna talk about that gap and what that cost is of not working on that messaging.
Alane (29:03)
Yeah, so yeah, I feel like we did talk about that a little bit before of, know, when you're saying generic and kind of being your messaging is for everyone or blends in with everybody. I mean, the biggest cost is obviously going to be you are going to stall on your business because nobody's going to know that you are specifically for them. And in my opinion, like honestly, I think that messaging is one of the
most expensive leaks inside of your business because you don't see it happening. You can't see who popped over to your Instagram or saw you, know, saw a pretty picture of your work on their Instagram feed popped over. But then they were kind of confused about what you do or if you work for people like them or what you offer. And so they just left. Like we you don't see that. And so
One of the things that I hear all the time is people being like, I need more visibility, I need more content, I need more eyes on my business, I need more SEO. it's like, if you don't work on your messaging first, like good luck. mean, Cat, you said it yourself. Like as soon as you dialed in on your messaging, everything else became so much easier for you, for creating content, for how you were talking about your services, for how you were pitching yourself, like all of those things. So before you do any of that, like,
it's time to get specific first and foremost, because otherwise you're just going to be adding more noise into your business, right? Like maybe you are getting leads right now. But if they're not the that they're not aligned leads, you're just wasting admin time on them basically. But if you kick up the volume, you might get more but now you have even more admin work on your plate. So like, I would never say to turn up the volume on any kind of marketing until you work on your messaging first and foremost.
Alex (30:42)
I can attest to that too, because I do think there were a few periods and it was probably the 2020-2021 time where we were all kind of lost of trying to do those viral videos, or whatever all the other calligraphers, all the other artists were doing online and replicating trends. And I think
I look back and I go, like that wasn't you. Why are you doing that? So
Alane (31:07)
Yep.
Alex (31:07)
that's kind of an example of you're not really doing anything that's representative of you. You're just following a trend. And while that might land people on your Instagram or your website, what is that even saying?
How is that impacting your ROI at the long-term?
Alane (31:24)
Right, exactly.
Cat (31:25)
So as we're like talking through this, I feel like we're talking a lot about where things need to be clear and I wanna start moving into maybe some tangible things that people are like more concrete ways that people can look at their own messaging and assess it. So I feel like maybe we help them focus on who their audience is.
is being a good start and like making sure that we're creating content for the audience that you're wanting to attract.
Alane (31:51)
Yep. Yeah, I think
this is such an easy trap that we can fall into. And I'm guilty as charged granted now like take it with a grain of salt because my business is a little bit different because I am now looking to attract calligraphers to me. Um, but I do find that as calligraphers, we tend to create content for other calligraphers, not necessarily for our clients. And I get why it happens because we are
such a unique, beautiful niche industry. And I feel like there's nothing quite like connecting with another calligrapher who just gets what you're going through. and that can have a time and a place, but if you are literally making a piece of content that you're hoping to turn into a client or at least an inquiry, then it cannot be speaking to a calligrapher. Like those two people are gonna have very different.
questions and those questions are gonna require different kinds of content, right?
Alex (32:47)
well, one of the ways that that shows up for me is when I have more calligraphers commenting on a post of mine than my
Alane (32:56)
Mm-hmm.
Cat (32:57)
Hmm.
Alex (32:58)
clients and friends and whoever's following me. Like I had just posted something about doing serifs and I was trying to educate for clients how it takes more time and skill.
And I had just artists commenting on it being like, yeah, it does. This is so hard. And I go, shit, like, what did I say that attracted, not that I don't appreciate the support and the solidarity and how fucking
Cat (33:21)
Yeah.
Alex (33:22)
hard the narratives are. And it was like, shit, like, what did I say that maybe didn't land or,
Cat (33:27)
didn't land with the right, yeah.
Alex (33:29)
yeah. So I think that's like maybe a concrete example
Cat (33:32)
well, and I think that's
where people get lost in that trap too is because it's not that we're not all trying to have a viral moment, because we do but if you are creating content and your content that you create gets the most engagement from other calligraphers your natural instinct is to continue to make content that's going to create engagement. So if the only posts that do well for you are the ones
that other calligraphers are commenting on or all of those things, then that's the trap you're gonna get in over and over again. So, and I think too, and maybe this will tie us back, really sure, we're gonna find out. But when you get so clear on your messaging, it really makes it easier to brush off like, maybe that post didn't get a lot of engagement. Like to be so fucking for real, I...
just make content for my clients now, like whether or not it does really, I mean, I love when they do really well, but when it doesn't, I really don't care because it's not like that, it's meant to serve as a portfolio for people to scroll in my feed and see credibility. So I don't care.
A bunch of calligraphers don't comment or I don't care if it doesn't do well numbers wise, it's not the purpose of it. And I feel so much better when I'm putting that content together because I know what that content is trying to do and it's not to go viral. Like it's got a different job.
Alane (34:47)
Right? No, I mean, exactly.
Right. That's exactly it. Yeah. And I feel like to your point, it's like, we think that our content is working because it is getting all of that positive reinforcement. It's getting all of that engagement with which then just feeds the cycle. But to your point, and what I've even noticed is like, your clients probably aren't going to be commenting or liking necessarily, but they might be saving, they might be saving it to their wedding inspo folder their live event.
folder, you know, like, exactly, exactly. And that's engagement that you can't. Right,
Cat (35:15)
They're sending it to their director. They're screenshotting it and putting it in their mood board.
Alane (35:23)
right. And that's engagement that you can't necessarily see, but it is doing something for you. And, you know, I think you have to remember that your clients are most likely going to be quiet lurkers on your business page. So you can't just run it off of like wanting that instant gratification necessarily.
But yeah, it's like, think that, you know, when we're creating content for other calligraphers to your point, I feel like the telltale sign is just getting a ton of engagement from other calligraphers, which again, that could have a time and a place and it creates community connections and all of that. So like, I think that's fine to an extent, but if you are literally like, I need to get inquiries coming into my business right now, then maybe pause on that content.
Cat (36:02)
Yeah.
Alane (36:02)
And you should only be creating content for your ideal client because again, like I said, that client is not necessarily there to figure out how you do what you do. Like, yes, maybe the process is interesting to her. I do think that there can be value in bringing people behind the scenes. But at the end of the day, your ideal client is probably asking like, will this person understand what I'm looking for? Are they gonna get my vision? Am I gonna trust her to bring my
Cat (36:27)
Yeah.
Alane (36:28)
wedding or my event to life?
What would working with this person feel like? Is it going to feel easy? Is it going to feel like pulling teeth? Those are the types of questions that are going through your client's head, not necessarily how do you make a seating chart.
Cat (36:40)
right, well, and to that point, like.
You can make a piece of content and just tailor it again for your audience, but you need to know who your audience is. So you could do the same get ready with me style video where you're showing all the things you're packing. If the way you edit that for another calligrapher's eye, maybe you want like affiliate purchases or whatever else is like, I'm going to show you all the shit I pack and like how I pack it and how I organize it. That is BTS content that is geared towards other calligraphers. It's going to get a bunch of people in your DMs and in your comments.
asking for the links for all your shit. Your clients don't care. They literally don't care. But you can shoot that same style content. You could even probably use the same B-roll to be honest with you. But if your voiceover is now, hey, I packed these 97 million things. I packed three engravers and two foilers and all of those things because I'm ready to pivot if my shit dies. You can trust me that.
I've got a backup plan. I'm packing all these paint pens because if my foiler doesn't work for some god awful reason, maybe you're at stage coach and it's 45 mile an hour winds. Like I can pivot and now use a paint pen. Like that is the same visual content, but it is now tailored for my audience, which is my client, the people that I want to like, know and trust me. Does that like, hopefully that ties into what we're talking about.
Alane (37:56)
No, think that's a great
example. No, I think that's a great example. Cause it's also like, you don't have to reinvent the wheel. Like you don't need to
Cat (38:02)
Mm-mm.
Alane (38:03)
make this more complicated and literally post both of them. Cause both of those sounded like great posts. Get your affiliate revenue and get your client.
Alex (38:11)
Okay, so those are some good tips so far. And I was hoping that maybe we could give people a little bit more what some other tips that maybe people could use when they're trying to kind of clarify their messaging.
Alane (38:24)
Yeah. So first I would say like do an audit. So if you are thinking, okay, my I think
my messaging needs some work audit what you currently have. Pull up your Instagram bio, your website homepage, an inquiry reply, any of those things and ask yourself, does this tell someone who it's for? And basically why they should care or like what's in it for them a bit within the first few seconds? Does it make the right person or your ideal client feel found?
If not, then that is definitely a sign to tweak it. And kind of like we said before, the very first piece of your messaging is really gonna be getting clear on who you are for and who you're not for. And that's really only work that you yourself can do. Like I said, I could give you the prompts or I could give you guidelines and things like that, but nobody's gonna be able to hand you that answer. One of the things that I like to do is almost start backwards. like figuring out what I know I don't want.
the types of clients I know I don't want to work with, the types of projects I know I don't want to do, because sometimes that feels less overwhelming than getting so specific on what it is that you do want. And then it kind of like reveals itself.
Alex (39:29)
Like if you're Alex, you don't want weddings. And I say that
Cat (39:33)
you
Alex (39:33)
a million times.
Cat (39:35)
and we don't want retail and I will never
make content attracting retail.
Alane (39:39)
Exactly. So I would definitely start there. And then, you know, yes, I would also say like, you're you need to do work on you your values, like to Alex's point before as well of just like getting really clear on what's important to you and what your vibe is and how you want to be presenting yourself to the world, etc. But a lot of it is also going to be about your ideal client.
I hate client avatar, like work.
Cat (40:03)
It makes no fucking sense to me.
Alane (40:05)
Like what, where does she like to shop? What's her age? Like I'm like, no. Right. I'm like, none of that
Cat (40:09)
I don't care. I don't care.
Alane (40:12)
actually matters. in my opinion, it's more like, what is that person actually looking for? What are the things that care that they care about? What are they motivated by? What problem do they need solved?
how can you specifically solve that problem? How do you do it differently than others in your industry? So really thinking through like, what does that person look like? And I mean, if you have past clients that you're like, that was a favorite client, use that person as an example, or to help you kind of start digging into that client avatar work. And if you haven't worked with anybody before, like if you're brand new to calligraphy, I would say just start to think about like,
what your values are and the type of person that you would actually want to be working with. And you can start there. And granted, like, you're going to learn a lot as you're just getting started. No.
Alex (40:59)
And it never ends. mean, we're always
practicing. We're always figuring it out. We're always going, oop, didn't like that. Oop, actually, that's okay now. Actually, this, you know, like, so I think, I don't think it's, you just reflect once and then you're done. I think fortunately and unfortunately, it's part of the work of being a business owner is that you're.
constantly reflecting on all of these things. And so it's really
Alane (41:20)
Right.
Alex (41:21)
important to have people in your life who do the same thing as you that you can chat with and or coaches and mentors and people that you can listen to and learn from that can help you through that.
Alane (41:33)
Yep. Yeah. Permission to evolve.
Alex (41:36)
Exactly.
Cat (41:35)
permission to evolve
and then something else we feel like well I definitely say on the podcast all the time is like if you're in that reflective state I highly recommend that you mute other calligraphers accounts
Truly like you don't have to unfollow them. I notoriously do not follow a bunch of people I'm sorry like that's what our podcast pages for I just it throws me into a tailspin when I start seeing other people's content when I start like it really just throws me off like I can't do it and that honestly was the first thing I did way back in the day when I was like I'm about to get so fucking for real about myself and my own business was I just like muted a bunch of people I really highly recommend doing that because I just
find it so difficult to get out of the same hamster wheel when you're continuing to see other people's messaging, other people's copy, other people's content. Like it's just very hard to generate your own thought when you're just constantly seeing other people served up on a silver platter, especially if you are in a state where you're.
working on your growth mindset or something like that and now you're seeing like their analytics or the events that they're doing or whatever else like you're just gonna continue to have a hard time getting clarity if you continue to just look and see other people's things that are adding to your confusion.
Alex (42:52)
And I think an example of this is, you know, how people get writer's block or you hear stories of more historical writers where they went and touched grass. They went to the bar and they got life experience and then they were finally able to write. It's kind of like that, I think. Live your life.
Cat (43:10)
Yeah.
Alane (43:10)
Yeah. Right.
Alex (43:12)
Meet people that are not doing what you do.
and you can figure out who you are by process of elimination and by process of practice.
Alane (43:20)
Yep, exactly. Yeah. One of my like biggest rules for myself is if I'm if I need to create anything, whether it's like I need to write an Instagram post or plan out my content or write an email or plan out curriculum even for my program. It's like my number one rule is to create anything before I consume. like I will not let myself get online and start scrolling before I put myself in like a creation mode because I want to make sure that I can get everything out of my head that is uniquely mine first.
before I go and do like any kind of research or if I am looking for some inspiration or an analogy or like a reference to pull into it, you know, I don't want that to hit me first. I wanna make sure that it's coming out of my head first.
Cat (44:01)
Yeah,
I kind of do the same thing. I'll feel like I'll put together kind of like if I'm doing like a voice over reel or something like that, like I'll put down like these are the things I want to talk about. This is how loosely I want to edit it. And I'll work through that process first. And then I'll go look for a trending audio to put in the background or something like that. I'm trying to reverse engineer it. I don't want to be sitting there scrolling one and wasting my time, but to then just like whether I'm purposely doing it or not. Now I'm filling my deal with like, the way they edited that was cool. And I want to do that or did it like
I try really hard to reverse engineer it, I avoid doing that to the best of my abilities.
Alex (44:35)
Yeah, and I think Alane you wrote this in your notes, so hopefully it's okay that I'm kind of mentioning it, but I mean,
Alane (44:40)
Go for it.
Alex (44:41)
you wrote that... You wrote that, you know, it's tempting to turn to AI, chat GBT and Claude to write your messaging, but they don't fucking know you.
Alane (44:51)
No. Nope.
Cat (44:51)
No. And they're pulling from other things
on the internet that are similar. It's going to end you in the same fucking trap.
Alane (44:56)
Exactly. Exactly.
Alex (44:59)
Mm-hmm.
Alane (44:59)
And I put like to your point, one of my like top tips and I shared this with people in my program. I do this myself all the time. But your like best messaging yet it's going to come from inside of you first and foremost, but then also it's going to come from your clients. So like, what are they saying?
inquiry, you know, as they're filling out your contact form, what are they saying in emails? What are they saying in reviews? What are they saying on discovery calls? Like record your discovery calls, if you're not doing that, that's such a great way to like goldmine what your ideal client actually wants, what they're thinking, what their questions are, which can then, I mean, questions alone can inform like so many different types of content for you.
Cat (45:39)
Yeah. And if you don't have the clients yet because you're in an earlier stage in your business,
people around you, like what would your friends say about you? If you have a partner, what would your partner say about you? Like, especially those that know you're stepping out into this business venture, what are they excited to see about from you? Or like, what do they see in you as a business owner? And your secret sauce. Like I know for me, like my poor husband has to be banging his head on the fucking wall half the time because he'll tell me all of these things. And I'm like, I don't know, I why I believe you. I'm gonna go do it the hard way for like six months and then we'll circle back and.
Do this later, but like he just truly sees something in my blind spot that I just can't see and so if you don't have clients yet maybe you don't have biz besties yet because you're new in the industry still like look for people that have your best interest in heart and can see in your blind spot and have used them as a resource, but you can also do that even if you have clients
Alex (46:35)
for those of us who are kind of not sure if they need help with messaging, they're kind of like, well, I do work with ideal clients or I do feel okay. Like what are some signs that maybe, maybe it is working for them and you're on the right track.
Cat (46:51)
And you should double down.
Alane (46:52)
Yeah, I... Yeah.
feel like for me, and this is just based on what like I've seen in my own business, as well as what I've seen in the calligraphers businesses that I've worked with, but usually a great sign that you are on the right track with your messaging is the inquiries that are coming in are usually pretty aligned, like you will always probably still get like a weird one off that you're like, how did you end up here? But you're getting the inquiries in and you're like, this is exactly what
I do they understand what how I can help them. They understand how we can bring this to life, etc. So those are aligned, you're not getting a ton of pricing pushback. Like I remember being so dialed in on my messaging. I think this was last year with a couple weddings that I booked where it was like I was getting inquiries, they were putting their budget as like my lowest range, which was like three to four. And they were signing five and $6,000 wedding proposals, no questions asked because
of how I was guiding them through that process. mean, that's probably a combination of messaging and client experience, but still, they were coming in already ready to invest with me.
Cat (47:56)
to spend, yeah.
Alane (47:57)
Right. So I would definitely look at who's coming into your inbox, how are people responding to your proposals and things like that? Are you getting a lot of budget objections or are you not? Are people asking a lot of questions? Are they confused on any part of the process or do they seem pretty clear of like,
how everything works and they're just kind of letting you guide them. Yeah.
Alex (48:18)
Yeah, the third time
someone asked me a question, just go, okay,
I put it in 10 places,
but I guess I'll make another place for you to find this and read it.
Alane (48:27)
Yeah, well,
unfortunately, like people don't really read everything. So we say that all the time. But did that answer your question of just like some of the signs that people can look out for for when they know their messaging
Alex (48:40)
Yeah.
Alane (48:41)
is working?
Alex (48:41)
Yeah, no, 100%. 100%.
Alane (48:44)
Awesome.
Alex (48:44)
Yeah, so I do think I think we have a pretty good handle on
when your messaging might not be working and when your messaging is working. So I'm curious if you want to leave us with anything else or where people can find you if they're listening to this and they're like, wait, no, I do need help. Or maybe I'm not sure. Like, please tell me yes or no.
what do you got going on?
Alane (49:08)
So for now, the best place that you can find me and see what I'm up to would be following me on Instagram. It's at write pretty for me.
that's where I'm, you know, sharing what I'm working on how I'm helping calligraphers, but I love connecting in DMS. So if you do have a question about your messaging, you can always pop in usually I'll just take a quick peek at your bio and be like, here's a tip to improve it or I think you're nailing this or whatever the case may be. But I think by the time this comes out, we probably I don't think I'll have an open cohort of flourishing biz, but I will be enrolling one in the fall, that'll be the next one. So if messaging is feeling like
that is something that you wanna focus on. That's like I said, the very first thing that we do inside of that program because then everything else that we build your systems and your client experience, all of that's gotta run on your messaging foundation first. So we can't jump ahead.
Alex (49:54)
Okay, so you have flourishing biz and that's more of a long, long term investment or long term program where sorry, can you walk through that?
Alane (50:01)
Yep, that's a 12 week. Yeah, yep.
Yeah, it's a 12 week group coaching program for calligraphers, stationers and live event artists. And I take you through kind of like the three pillars of your business foundation, which is your messaging first and foremost, because as we've already discussed, everything is built off of that, then we make sure that your client experience is designed to actually convert the people that are coming into your door and not just convert them.
but also turn them into repeat clients, referrals, turn them into natural upsells, like just increase the average project value of your clients because I feel like we're always trying to look for our next sale and it's like nine times out of 10, it's actually already like in your inbox or already in your world. So like, let's not spin our wheels. And then we put all of that into system. So that way you've got workflows and automations built, which then just increases your time and your capacity. So you can either.
take on more clients or just take time off and live your life or whatever you want to do.
Alex (51:00)
I love that. No, that program sounds great and kind of, it seems like it kind of does it all. It's like, we'll work through the messaging as well as the systems and how to get the clients and all that. So that's, think, perfect for a lot of people because one thing always seems to relate to the other thing and having them all in one little, one little program is great. So love that.
Alane (51:20)
Yeah.
Cat (51:20)
Yeah,
I feel like to what I see from like the people that come out of your programs is there's just like this renewed confidence about them. And that really comes from a mentor that isn't just telling them like what to do or why but really coaching them as to like
how to think about their own business in their own way, that they can feel comfortable in the decisions they're making, they understand the why, and that really is a testament to you and your coaching, and I just really wanted to say that because I feel like that is such an important thing, and I'm excited to see how you continue to grow your business.
Alane (51:53)
You're so sweet. Thank you so much. You're gonna make me cry.
Cat (51:55)
You
Alex (51:57)
Okay, so with that, we know where to find you on socials. Once this is finally recorded, edited, uploaded to the Zeitgeist, we will have show notes with the links to whatever you have going on so that people can find you. Our pod is keeping up with the calligs
And we're so grateful that you came on today. We're so excited for people to know you if they don't know you already and hear about this conversation because I think it is definitely important to be had. And yeah, thanks for coming on and thanks everybody else for
Alane (52:28)
Thank
Alex (52:28)
keeping up.
Alane (52:29)
you so much for having me.
Cat (52:31)
Thanks for giving up, bye!
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Calligraphy Biz Corner
Shaochen Wu
Talk with Renee Dalo
Renee Dalo